Shelter Island, NY Area Hotels

Name by letter
Click the letter below to show only hotels starting with that letter. You may also type all or part of a hotel name in the box above to find all hotels that contain the entered name. A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z ALL
Hotel Preferences
Meal Plans Offered
Hotel Type
Number of Rooms

Set Search Radius
0 miles
Drag or click to zoom in or out the search radius. Only Hotels that fall within 6 miles from the city center will be shown.
Choose Your View
6First Class
The American Hotel49 Main St PO Box 1349
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
8 Rooms

1800's inn - Located on Main St....

DetailsView on Map
5Limited Service First Class
Harborfront Inn at Greenport209 Front St
Greenport, NY 11944
35 Rooms
Commission: 10%$239-$499(USD)
DetailsView on Map
4Moderate First Class
Pridwin Hotel & CottagesCrescent Beach, Shore Rd PO Box 2009
Shelter Island, NY 11964
49 Rooms

Holiday Hotel & Cottages set on private beach....

Commission: 10%$229-$309(USD)
DetailsView on Map
Arbor View House Bed & Breakfast8900 Main Rd PO Box 226
East Marion, NY 11939
4 Rooms

This 4 room property, built in 1780......

DetailsView on Map
Baron's Cove Inn31 W Water St
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
67 Rooms

2 story cedar shingled building, overlooking marina and harbor on historic waterfront, one-half mile from Main Street....

DetailsView on Map
The Blue Inn at North Fork-East Marion7850 Main Road
East Marion, NY 11939
29 Rooms

This 29 room property, renovated in 2011......

DetailsView on Map
Chequit Inn23 Grand Ave
Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965
37 Rooms

This 37 room property, renovated in 2015......

Commission: 10%
DetailsView on Map
Forever Bungalows765 Rte 114
Sag Harbor, NY 11963
DetailsView on Map
The Greenporter326 Front St
Greenport, NY 11944
30 Rooms

This 30 room property, built in 2001......

DetailsView on Map
Harbor Knoll Bed & Breakfast424 4th St
Greenport, NY 11944
DetailsView on Map