Should racial or ethnic profiling be used at airports to root out terror suspects?
This page is protected by Copyright laws. Do Not Copy.

Study: Cleaner cruise ship restrooms may reduce norovirus incidence

November 04, 2009

Cleaner public restrooms on cruise ships may decrease the incidence of norovirus, according to a study published in medical journal Clinical Infectious Diseases.

A team of Boston-based universities and health organizations found "widespread poor compliance" with cleaning protocols on 56 ships the team visited over a three-year period.

According to the report, only 37% of toilet area objects were cleaned on a daily basis in 273 randomly selected public restrooms.

The researchers said that since norovirus outbreaks frequently occur among closed populations and because environmental contamination is believed to play an important role in its propagation, they concluded that enhanced public restroom cleaning may prevent or moderate norovirus outbreaks on cruise ships.

The team said that in doing its research, it "covertly evaluated the thoroughness of disinfection cleaning" of six bathroom objects – the toilet seat, flush handle or button, toilet stall inner handhold, stall inner door handle, restroom inner door handle and baby changing table.

It did not specify which cruise ships it had visited.

The study said that its findings did not correlate with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's Vessel Sanitation Program inspection scores. More than half of the vessels that received poor scores in the recent study were given near-perfect CDC sanitation scores, according to the study.

CLIA issued a statement in response to the study.

"The limitations of this research raise appropriate questions that must be answered before a more complete assessment is reached," CLIA said. "It is worth highlighting that the [study] was not designed to investigate the causal relationship – and did not find one – between the thoroughness of disinfecting public restrooms and outbreaks aboard cruise ships.”

CLIA also said that its public health and sanitation procedures “go above and beyond this study’s focus on the disinfecting of public restrooms” and are “highly effective in maintaining healthy settings for families on vacation.

According to the CDC, the vast majority of norovirus outbreaks take place at land-based locations such as schools, daycare centers, hospitals and nursing homes.

From 1 to 5 of 10 Comment(s)

Leave a Comment

#10November 10, 2009
You can clean the restrooms but that don't make the people clean their hands. It is disgusting the amount of people that don't wash their hands after relieving themselves. It is also the same people that make the restrooms so nasty. If these patrons would be more considerate and not such pigs there wouldn't be these problems. You would think that they are still living in a 3rd world country. Can imagine what their house looks like. No wonder they go on a cruise, they need to get out of their own cesspool.
#9November 10, 2009
Having been on a HAL cruise right after a cruise with an outbreak, I can personall attest to the great job done to halt the visus from spreading to the next group. But cruise ships and any other public vehicles carrying people can only do so much. People are selfish and would not consider cancelling their trip if the felt they are comming down with something. We fly all the time next to people who look and sound like they are really sick. Please encourage the sale of travel insurance so people can cancel their trips if they are ill and encourage your travelers to be rersponsible. Also remember to use sanitizer after taking food from a buffet and before you eat and touch your silverware and napkin. You do not know what is on those handles!
#8November 07, 2009
wash wash wash & wash some more...use sanitizers. Also the ships i have been on recently have little plastic towles to open the doors with and lots of sanitiers all over the ship, especially when entering dining rooms. I think the cruise lines do all they can...they are always cleaning and it's up to the guests to take all precautions. marilyn
#7November 06, 2009
As far as I'm concerned, most cruise ships 'look' clean, but it certainly doesn't them hurt to have a more intense cleaning schedule.
#6November 05, 2009
The study says they used a target solution that requires mild abrasion to remove, and if it isnt removed they determined the object was not cleaned. Interesting that spraying with a disinfectant is an approved disinfection technique for many of these objects. Maybe this study shows nothing. Shouldn't the researchers have reviewed cleaning disinfecting protocols before engaging in their COVERT study or at least before publishing it.
View All Comments

Leave a Comment

Comment Guidelines

Your
Comment:
characters remaining