Among the snippets of conversation that ended up on the cutting-room floor after editing the Travel Weekly Consumer Travel Editors Roundtable ["Editors Roundtable: Something to talk about"], which appears in this week's print edition, was the confession that few of the editors in the room watch travel shows on television.

"There's an entire cable channel devoted to travel," I said. "Does anyone at this table watch it?"

Budget Travel's Erik Torkells said he doesn't have cable. Conde Nast Traveler's Klara Glowczewska said she "used to watch it occasionally." Town & Country's Heidi Mitchell found that "usually when I turn it on, it's a poker tournament." Travel + Leisure's Nancy Novogrod answered, "Not much. However, we have a show on it called 'Trips of a Lifetime.' "

USA Today's Veronica Stoddart likes Rick Steves on PBS, and Mitchell finds the Travel Channel show "Anthony Bourdain: No Reservations" to be fun.

But beyond that, there was little interest among the group to view travel shows.

Novogrod speculated, "If I didn't work in travel, I'd probably feel more of a desire to, you know, go home and curl up and watch travel." But I wonder. People I know who aren't in travel will bring up the Food Network and HGTV in conversation, but I can't recall the last time anyone mentioned something they watched on the Travel Channel.

Though the world is, in ample measure, visually stunning, video as a medium appears to be struggling to communicate its appeal under the appellation "travel" to this group.

National Geographic Traveler's Keith Bellows has some experience in both print and TV. He did a stint at ESPN, and his parent company has an eponymous network that is available in 60 countries and is watched by more than 3 million households. "I go to them all the time saying, 'We have this great travel idea,' and they say, 'Remember, Bellows, travel is the T word. Go away.' "

So what's the deal? Why should this be? To deepen the mystery, the editors were in agreement that travel can do well on TV, as long as it isn't positioned as travel.

"'The Love Boat' did more for the industry than anyone could have imagined," Torkells observed. Part of the formula for "The Amazing Race" and "Survivor," it was noted, is the lure of exotic locations, from Borneo to the Marquesas Islands.

After being told bluntly by his network's producers that the word "travel" carried a stigma, Bellows came back to them with another idea that's currently in development. "It is travel, but it's not called travel. They love it," he said.

In the end, travel may be a word whose meaning is so broad and all-encompassing that it fails to convey any specific or visceral connection at all. Or the most easily touched visceral connections may be negative: For too many people, the hassles associated with travel have become inseparable from the word.

Or perhaps it's simply that watching a video about a stranger on holiday is unappealing, no matter how smart and good-looking the stranger, how much fun he or she appears to be having and how beautiful the backdrop is.

Ultimately, when we say we love to travel, that's just shorthand for saying we love art, culture, food, politics, history and people (or, maybe, just that we're seeking relaxation). Anyone who has traveled with a group, or even a single companion, becomes keenly aware that there are varying travel styles, each attuned to the underlying interests and needs of the individual.

The travel industry has picked up on this to varying degrees, with travel agents becoming specialists rather than generalists, with the segmentation of the cruise industry, with tour operators selling "discovery" rather than tours.

"There is no such thing as the travel industry," Bellows summed up. "It's life."

Comments
JDS Travel News JDS Viewpoints JDS Africa/MI