Greenport, NY5.1 miles
Modern, overlooking Shelter Island - Off Route 25, near Peconic Bay.
View Hotel Details
7 Superior First Class
Commission: 10%
Rooms: 32
Rates: -
Greenport, NY5.9 miles
Modern, directly on Long Island Sound with sun decks facing water - 2 miles from Greenport Village.
6 First Class
Commission: -
Rooms: 65
Greenport, NY4.3 miles
Overlooking the Peconic Bay and Greenport village - 6-minute drive to Kontokosta Winery and easy access to Mitchell Park.
5 Limited Service First Class
Rooms: 35
Rates: $249 - $499
Shelter Island, NY6.4 miles
Holiday Hotel & Cottages set on private beach.
4 Moderate First Class
Rooms: 49
Rates: $224 - $354
Shelter Island Heights, NY5 miles
This 37 room property, renovated in 2022...
Not Yet Rated
Rooms: 37
Rates: $195 - $695
Greenport, NY5.5 miles
Rooms: 68
Rates: $159 - $299
Shelter Island Heights, NY4.7 miles
Lodge style, 7-acre site directly on Dering Harbor - Overlooking Dering Harbor.
Rooms: 23
Greenport, NY4.4 miles
Retro 1950s-style hotel waterfront park and hypoallergenic furnishings-3-minute walk from both the nearest beach.
Rooms: 30
Rates: $81 - $81
This 5 room property, built in 1870...
Rooms: 5
Rates: $325 - $325
Southold, NY7.1 miles
This 20 room property, renovated in 2012...
Rooms: 20
Rates: $129 - $349