Six executives from six sectors of the travel industry hotel, cruise, aviation, tours, retail and destination marketing are making assumptions about the year ahead as they plan for 2017. The interviews were conducted by Travel Weekly editor in chief and senior vice president Arnie Weissmann.
Goh Choon Phong
CEO, Singapore Airlines
We don't see 2017 to be very different from the year that just
passed. The U.S. economy has grown, and I think looks fairly positive.
In Europe, we're still seeing weakness. India, of course, is growing
Goh Choon Phong
Southeast Asia is generally healthy, but it isn't even. It's still a
growth region with a fair bit of potential, with some countries
Vietnam, Philippines growing well. But with others Malaysia and
Singapore, for example it's a bit of a slowdown.
China, yes, there's a slowdown, but it's a slowdown on a very big
base. It's still a significant economic force, and we expect that to
continue. We're seeing reasonable traffic coming out of China, though
there's a perceptible slowdown in the premium segment. But Chinese
travelers are still coming out and visiting the rest of the world. Japan
and Korea benefit the most because of proximity and the weakness of the
North Asia, inbound, is not an issue, but traffic into Europe has not
grown as much. Outbound to America, that's a bit challenging. Demand
has stayed regular between Australia and Europe.
For close to a decade now, we've noticed that there is actually a
structural change in the industry. Lots of capacity is being added by
the long-haul Middle Eastern and Chinese carriers and short-haul,
low-cost carriers (LCCs). Southeast Asia has seen a huge proliferation
of LCC players, rapidly growing from almost nothing to hundreds of
aircraft. In fact, Southeast Asia now has the highest concentration of
LCCs in the world, in excess of 50% of market share. In Europe, it's
only in the high 30s.
So the question for us was: What do we do? How do we strengthen ourselves in this new environment?
What we have done is quite a departure from the last 60 years. We had
always been an airline that's focused on full, high-premium service and
product, with Singapore as a hub for worldwide, organic growth.
But over the last five to six years, we have branched out to set up a
portfolio of airlines. We started up Scoot, an LCC targeted at
medium-to-long haul, operating 12 Boeing 787s. We have [regional LCC]
Tigerair, which we are now integrating with Scoot for greater synergy
and connectivity. They're able to penetrate markets that had demand but
that cannot be viably served by the full-service model. In the past we
didn't have the right vehicle to serve it. We expect that Scoot and
Tigerair will contribute even more significantly to the underlying
profit of the group in the future.
For full service, we still have Singapore Airlines, which is
operating widebody, medium-haul and long-haul, and we have SilkAir,
which is a full-service regional operation. So it's all there and gave
us a lot of flexibility to deploy the right tool to respond to strength
Demand changes over time. For example, we used to operate Singapore
Airlines to Athens, with a full-service provision. But it wasn't
economically viable because there wasn't enough premium traffic. There
was a lot of leisure, and visits to friends and relatives, so we dropped
the route from Singapore Airlines, and it will be operated by Scoot
next year. Scoot is more than 45% lower in terms of unit cost compared
to Singapore Airlines and can be profitable on that route.
It can work the other way around as well. We have operations that
started off with LCCs and then moved in our portfolio as the traffic
built up with more premium travelers.
I mentioned our traditional focus on Singapore as a hub, with organic
growth from there. It's great for servicing Southeast Asia and the
Southwest Pacific, and we continue to strengthen the network into both.
But the Middle Eastern carriers may be better positioned
geographically for some markets because they reach more land mass within
six or seven hours. So if, for instance, somebody from India, which is a
huge market, wishes to fly to Europe, they wouldn't come via Singapore.
So we looked to set up a joint venture overseas. By 2025, India will be
the third-biggest travel market in the world after China and the U.S.
And India-based carriers that are operating internationally still have,
relative to other foreign carriers, a small footprint internationally.
We set up Vistara, a joint venture with Tata Sons, and started
operations in 2015 with 13 aircraft. India, to be sure, is a very
difficult market to operate in, and there's a lot of LCC capacity, so we
have to nurture it well. But it has already achieved a great reputation
as having the best product and services in India.
This portfolio approach is important because it gives us the
nimbleness and flexibility to deploy the right aircraft for the right
competition for the right route to serve the right segment. And that is
quite key to the way we actually are able to manage the market dynamics.
With overseas investment, we are very clear on what market is
suitable for what model. I think most people would acknowledge that
Thailand is a very attractive destination for budget-conscious
travelers. So NokScoot, our joint venture with Nok Air in Thailand, is a
regional LCC in Bangkok. With these joint ventures, you need to build
the right foundation, the right philosophy, the right service culture.
There are exciting changes ahead for Singapore Airlines as well. We
ordered 67 [Airbus] A350s, which will be a game changer for us. For a
while, we had not been growing long-haul because the existing equipment
wasn't fuel-efficient enough to serve long-haul in a viable manner. But
the A350s bring new capabilities. It's 20% to 25% more fuel efficient
and has the right capacity.
Our A350s configure in business, premium economy and economy for a
total of 253 seats. So it's not a very big aircraft, but has good range.
For example, we use it for Singapore to San Francisco. And we are using
it nonstop for secondary points in Europe, such as Dusseldorf, Germany,
which allows us to bring premium passengers from Singapore there
without having to stop in the Middle East. All things being equal,
passengers would rather fly nonstop. It is a compelling advantage to
really pick off most premium demand.
On top of that, we have also embarked on a fairly extensive
partnership program. Six or seven years ago, we had, systemwide, maybe
1,000-plus codeshares. Today, we're close to 10,000 codeshares, building
up partnerships with like-minded carriers. It goes beyond the Star
Alliance: Virgin America and JetBlue, for example, are partners.
Why is this important? Let's take a concrete example. We have an
extensive, joint-venture codeshare with Lufthansa, which includes a
revenue-sharing component. That's good for customers coming from
Singapore who want to travel to Europe where Lufthansa has great
regional connectivity. And it's equally good coming to Singapore, which
has similarly great connectivity, when flying from Europe. And we both
can provide a very attractive frequent-flyer program.
We are very happy to discuss this with United as well; United is a
Star Alliance partner, and I think a cross-alliance partnership is a bit
But there are also those who are not in an alliance, for example
JetBlue, Virgin America and others. So we will continue to look for
opportunities and cooperation with United, but we would also be open to
work with others if the United route network is not available.