Having endured two major pay cuts in three years and the
uncertainty of waiting for another one, travel retailers are angry,
unhappy and nervous right now -- just ripe for some time on the
therapist's couch.
In the name of
agents everywhere, we made an appointment with Manhattan-based
psychologist Jerry Croghan, Ph.D. Here's his prescription for the
collective agent psyche:
Recognize clearly what's happening -- times are changing, and
you have to change with them. Your relationship with the airlines
will never be the same, and if you haven't begun to rethink your
business, you should start immediately.Face up to the grieving process. Agents are experiencing "the
loss of their life as they knew it," said Dr. Croghan. There's
always some sadness in change; recognize the feeling and deal with
it so you're not unexpectedly sobbing at inappropriate
moments.Avoid the angry victim stance. "The more one indulges the
feeling of victimhood, the less control one has over one's life,"
said Dr. Croghan. "Pound a pillow or beat up your couch -- but then
move on to other things," he suggested.Fight your fear of feeling like an idiot while you learn new
things. It's uncomfortable, but necessary, to be a beginner again
-- whether you're just starting to surf the Net or developing a new
niche. "At least 70% of adults who are stuck in jobs they hate are
unwilling to face their own ignorance and feel like a child again,"
said Dr. Croghan.Recognize that travel isn't the only industry to change. With
managed health care, even doctors are facing pay cuts of almost
50%.Rejoice in the change. "Processing tickets has to be the least
interesting part of being an agent," said Dr. Croghan. So selling
less air "will free you for the creative aspects of travel."Relax, No Pretzels
Learning to relax and put your work behind you at the end of the
day is a key factor in psychological health, according to Travel
Weekly's checkup with therapist Dr. Croghan.
The book "Relax and Renew" can help you achieve this goal. It's
billed as a guidebook to "restful yoga poses," but don't let the
word yoga, with its images of pretzeled limbs, scare you off. The
poses are mostly as simple as lying down on the floor, supported by
pillows. "When practiced regularly, they will help you to heal the
effects of chronic stress in as little as five minutes a day,"
writes author Judith Lasater. "Think of them as taking a short
holiday right in your bedroom or living room." The book is
published by Romdell Press and costs $21.95.
Group Therapy
One of the
best ways for agents to gain a sense of control these days is to
network with their peers. That's what 10 Massachusetts-based agents
do each month, calling their meetings "group therapy," according to
Ginny Nissenbaum, president of Boston-based Touraine Travel and
Cruises. "We meet for support rather than political action," she
said.
Members of the group first connected when they were all agents
with the consortium Valu Travel Marketing, "and we really hit it
off," said Nissenbaum. When Valu was bought by Empress Travel, most
of the group left the consortium but kept in touch.
Members share industry gossip as well as tips -- for example, a
good article to reprint in their respective client newsletters.
Lately they've been making field trips to each other's agencies to
compare office procedures. Members of the group are not close
enough to one another geographically to be direct competitors,
except for two, who have learned to work it out between
themselves.
Swapping ideas has helped them replace a sense of passivity with
one of purpose. "We're more interested in pursuing ways to change
our businesses than in waiting for [the airlines] to do something
else to us," said Nissenbaum. "It's nice to talk to somebody in the
same position who's not going to lie to you. When you ask [a group
member] 'are you slow this week?' they'll feel comfortable enough
to say 'yes.' We're all in it together."
Take Control, Use Consolidators
Want to cut down
on your dependence on the major carriers and make a decent profit
while selling air? Work with consolidators.
If you've been avoiding these companies because you're afraid of
their fly-by-night reputation, it's time to relax, said Gary
Schmidt, author and publisher of the "Index to Air Travel
Consolidators," now available in its eighth edition. "Consolidators
appear to be more financially stable than many may expect," he
said. Seventy-two percent of the 180 firms listed in the book have
been in business 10 or more years, and nearly half of the
consolidators profiled reported annual sales of over $10 million.
The book is priced at $43.25 and is available by calling (800)
241-9299.
It pays to do some homework before trying to develop a
relationship with a consolidator. Schmidt's book provides a useful
first reference on any firm you're considering, since it includes
travel agent ratings on each consolidator, including information on
which companies have received many travel agent complaints. The
book also cross-references companies by destination so you can
broaden your base by working with some consolidators that handle
domestic as well as international bookings.
Also, ask the consolidator for the names of several of its best
clients who are retail agents and call them for a reference,
suggested Susan Tanzman, owner of Los Angeles-based Martin's Travel
& Tours. She'd also check with ASTA to see if there have been
any complaints filed against the company. A change of ownership in
the past three years is another red flag, she noted.
Tanzman would also see whether the company is an operator or an
agent. "I'd feel better if it was a tour operator, since as a
retail agent it wouldn't have the same insurance or protection as
would be required of a tour operator," she noted.
What's Coming Next?There is lots of speculation about what's happening next on the
airline commission front. In a survey on Crossroads nearly 90% of
more than 400 agents responding expected another pay cut.
Doris Davidoff, vice president of Belair Travel in Bowie, Md.,
for one, predicted a more variable structure, where "if you sell
well below market share, you're going to get 4%. If you sell more,
the airlines are going to work with you [and pay more]."
After commission cuts come net fares, the end of all commissions
-- which some agents said they'd welcome. Lucy Hirleman, owner of
Berkshire Travel, Newfoundland, N.J., thinks that net fares would
mean some agencies would be given discounted deals they could mark
up.
Others believe leisure net fares would work but only for large
agencies that could buy in bulk. "I think airlines wouldn't be
interested in doing it unless they had fairly large transactions,"
said Roger Block, executive vice president of the associate program
at Carlson Wagonlit. "We've had offers of bulk purchases that
involved net fares for a number of years off and on," said John
Noble, chairman of Minneapolis-based Northwestern Travel
Management."The trend is going that way, and I think you'll see
more of it. How far it filters down [to smaller agencies], I don't
know."
Both Block and Noble cited the recent reports of an upcoming
Amexco-Continental bulk fare deal as evidence of this trend. But
Noble doesn't think leisure net fares are coming soon. "There are
too many things going on in Washington with the airlines, and the
worst move they could make right now would be to fool around with
compensation," he said.
The Net Net
Though agents disagree about whether net fares are coming or
not, there is one area where net deals are alive and well: airline
consolidators. Many consolidators sell discounted tickets to agents
on a net basis; agents mark the price up to consumers. This is a
fact that some agents seem blissfully unaware of, judging by
several who recently complained about not getting commissions from
consolidators.
"Don't assume everyone pays commission," said Doris Davidoff,
industry educator and vice president of Belair Travel in Bowie, Md.
So although most consolidators may not think to mention how they
pay agents, that's one of the most important questions to ask
during a preliminary phone call, Davidoff said. Payment methods for
different consolidators also are listed in the book "Index to Air
Travel Consolidators." Call (800) 241-9299.