I recently saw a guest
list for an industry event where some attendees were tagged as VIP.
More were listed as MIP. I knew, of course, that VIP stands for
Very Important Person but wondered if the others were Merely
Important People.
But, no, it turns
out that MIP stands for Most Important Person and is actually a
higher designation than VIP. That there were more MIPs than VIPs
speaks to a serious form of inflation that needs to be addressed:
Star inflation.
Its not that
everyones a star -- these days, everyones three stars, if not three
stars-plus (a description a cruise-line exec recently used to
describe one of his ships).
When most of us
grew up, the ultimate in lodging was a four-star property. Some
hotels have now begun to describe themselves as six stars, and I
recently heard a hotelier claim seven. I have no doubt well see 10
stars in my lifetime, but for now, six seems to have gained
acceptance as the upper limit by a significant number of
hoteliers.
Those who believe
that we live in a six-star universe would likely agree that, for
example, New Yorks Waldorf-Astoria should belong in that
designation.
The problem with
star inflation, however, is that the addition of extra stars is not
necessarily a reflection of improvement. Is the Waldorf, as a
six-star hotel, 50% better than when it had only four
stars?
I know a thing or
two about the difficulty of classifying hotels. For a period, I was
head of a group of publications that included Star Service and the
Official Hotel Guide (OHG).
The former, which
provides critical reviews of hotels (www.starserviceonline.com), assigned a maximum of four
stars to properties but over the years added a Superstar
designation to indicate a truly exceptional property.
OHG had an
unbiased, 10-level classification system that ran from tourist
class to superior deluxe. (While OHG no longer exists, these
ratings now have been incorporated into Hotel and Travel Index and
Official Hotel Guide Worldwide.)
In addition, the
same parent company published the OAG Business Travel Planner,
which, using a computer algorithm, assigned hotels one to five
crowns. (Its now an online service at www.btp24.com.)
I cant tell you how
many hours were spent discussing ways to try to bring specific
criteria to the ratings. The problem was that we always found an
exception to every rule we tried to create. Should a Star Service
four-star property or OHG superior deluxe hotel, for instance, be
required to have a swimming pool?
If so, the Waldorf
-- and virtually every other great hotel in New York -- would be
excluded from the top designations. There were too many apples
mixed in with the oranges for any comparisons to be
meaningful.
There are two basic
underlying causes of star inflation. The first is the rise of mass
affluence and concurrent growth of mass-market properties that may
not be opulent but contain enough elements of luxury to lay claim
to being a luxury experience. This, not surprisingly, led to the
creation of the adjective ultraluxury, which really designates
complete luxury. Im not sure where it can go from here --
hyperluxury?
The second problem
is lack of consistency in ratings, compounded by the fact that the
majority of ratings are self-assigned, or assigned by a stupefying
range of self-credentialed authorities.
Ratings are by
nature subjective, but in this era of ubiquitous luxury, my
preference would be to see something along the lines of Michelin
restaurant ratings come into play for hotels.
Michelin has, to my
knowledge, never been tempted to assign more than three stars as
its top designation. To receive one star results in a celebration,
issuance of a press release and, for the chef, job security, a
contract to write a cookbook ... and instant status as an
MIP.
In this instance, a
star is born, not inflated.