The following article is for general information only and is
not intended to be a legal opinion or legal advice. For advice
about specific factual situations, consult an attorney.
Hiring for character is as important as selecting for computer
skills and sales ability.
In my law practice where I advise the owners and management of
agencies, I have found that people can be taught many things in the
office, but they have to walk in with impeccable integrity.
On a weekly basis, I am involved in a telephone consultation
with an agency owner that runs along the following lines:
"An agent in my office was hired quite some time ago, and we
were friendly, attending social celebrations together. She became
the manager of our agency. Two weeks ago, she left and stated that
she was leaving the industry. Now, a number of corporate clients
are calling, wondering why she has contacted them directly,
soliciting their business for a competing travel agency in town.
The Rolodex is missing from her desk, and she took her sales
journals with her."
Another scenario is the corporate on-site agent who has been at
a corporate client's office for two years. Suddenly, the agency
owner becomes aware that the corporate agency employee is shopping
the account to competitors. Moreover, the agency employee has been
offered a job by the corporate account and has switched loyalties
from the agency employer to the corporate client.
Does any of that sound familiar? What can be done?
Employment agreement
A written contract reflects the factual understanding of the
parties at the start of an employment relationship.
Even without a written agreement, a claim for unfair competition
can be brought on equitable grounds, such as tortious interference
with contractual relationships.
A written contract, however, carries the extra power of
predicting certain behavior and outlining how a breach should be
resolved.
I recommend that all employees be asked to sign an employment
agreement at the start of the employment relationship.
It should contain, at least, confidentiality provisions and a
covenant against the solicitation of your client database.
Components of an effective employment agreement essentially
reflect many of the following points:
Responsibilities of the employee. It is useful to lay out the
title and scope of what an employee is expected to do at your
agency.Devotion of full attention and energy, fulfillment of sales
goals and commitments to clients are usually included.
It is important also to address strict adherence to the rules of
ARC, the International Airlines Travel Agent Network, the Cruise
Lines International Association and state and federal law, and not
to allow issuance of travel documents until the agency has received
payment in full.
Term. The term of employment should be for an indefinite
duration.Maintaining the ability to hire and fire at will is important,
and, by the same token, realize that the employee has the right to
leave at will, too.
Some employment relationships are governed by written contracts,
which provide a contract term and state that the employee may be
terminated during the term of the contract only for "good cause" or
for "just cause."
These contracts are generally for chief executives of travel
companies, or they may be part of the agreement in the sale of an
agency where part of the payment for the agency is put into an
employment agreement with a former owner.
Both situations point out how the nature of the relationship
needs to rise to a certain level before the employer should agree
to diminished protections under the law.
Salary. I urge that a weekly or monthly salary be used.If the annual salary is the only figure mentioned, the agreement
might be construed as an annual contract, and therefore, if you, as
the employer, are found at fault, the full balance of an annual
salary could be included in damages.
Benefits. Only make promises that you know you will keep.Vacation and sick days. These can be set out in this contract
or in the employment manual.It is important to cancel such time if it has not been taken by
the end of each year in order to cancel the corresponding
obligation to pay.
Another consideration is setting out the required approval by
the employer prior to taking vacation time, and the type of notice
required for an accrued sick day.
It is wise to include this kind of information in both
employment contracts and employment manuals.
Nonsolicitation. Courts are more likely to enforce a
nonsolicitation agreement that pinpoints a specific clientele than
a blanket noncompetition agreement in an employment agreement with
a staffer.Statutes and case law vary from state to state; however, it is
understandable to a fact finder that an employer wants to keep his
clientele intact.
This kind of provision does not prevent an employee from going
to work for another entity in the agency industry.
However, it does lay out the parameters as to what is fair.
Such a provision may be very effective at preventing unfair
solicitations while the employee is still working at your agency as
well as after the employment has ended, whether voluntarily or
otherwise.
The type of information protected would include names of
clients, employees and vendors.
Confidentiality. A comprehensive confidentiality provision will
help prevent the loss of information which is unique to your
agency's business, such as files, names of clients, terms and
conditions of contracts with accounts, sales techniques, booked but
unexecuted tours, software processes developed by the travel agency
and all forms of computer data.No inducement of coworkers. You can help prevent the migration
of several staffers from one agency to another by including a
provision stating that the employee, upon leaving your agency, will
not induce other employees to follow for a specified period of
time.Fidelity bonding. My clients are consistently advised to obtain
fidelity bonding.Quite simply, it is insurance against theft by employees. It is
inexpensive and useful.
In an employment agreement, I always include a representation
that the employee is capable of being fidelity bonded, meaning that
there is no past history, which would prevent an insurance company
from writing insurance for the travel agency employer.
This lets the staffer know you will be obtaining a fidelity
insurance policy and causes the new staffer to provide some
assurance that you will be able to get the bond.
I encourage all employers to obtain such bonds for employees who
handle large amounts of money belonging to third parties.
Depending on state law, this could enable you to immediately
dismiss the individual who attested that he or she could be bonded
when that turned out to be false.
Reimbursement for losses. Some states allow you to deduct or
offset from salaries for debts, expenses (such as debit memos) or
losses incurred by the employer due to the employee's errors --
provided the employee has consented to the policy in writing.This issue comes up a lot with repeated debit memos associated
with the same employee who is told to stop an offending activity
but who continues to do it.
However, some states don't allow you to offset those losses from
employee salaries even if the staffers would consent because that
would be counter to those state's wage and hour laws, which state
an employee should be paid for time worked regardless of any
errors.
Limiting claims for compensation. Particularly for employees
who are paid on commission, it is a good idea to state that all
claims for commissions must be made within a specified period after
leaving the agency or there is no obligation to pay them.But a word of caution: Be sure to check your state law on this
matter so as not to run afoul of the wage and hour statutes.
In addition, if you pay commissions for new business attracted
by salaried staffers, insert a time frame after which no more
commissions will be payable in connection with that new
business.
No co-employment without consent.This requires the staffer to obtain the employer's consent prior
to accepting secondary employment in the travel industry, such as a
second job with another agency, tour operator or other
travel-related business.
Finally, when the newcomer joins your agency, it is useful to
have a list of "employee's clients" attached to the employment
agreement as an Exhibit A.The list then serves as a mutually agreed-upon separate group of
clients that the employee will or can take upon leaving
employment.
It is important to keep a copy in the employee's file.
Rose A. Hache is a Houston-based attorney whose practice is
travel law only. A former assistant counsel at ASTA headquarters,
she has been in her own practice for nearly 21 years.