
Mark Pestronk
Q: Travel Weekly published a report by Robert Silk in its Nov. 9 issue under the headline "NDC's struggle for acceptance." It stated, "The segment incentive issue continues to be a barrier to adoption among TMCs and traditional leisure agencies, even though the three GDSs have long since become a significant part of the NDC landscape, offering NDC content from sizable lists of partner airlines but under different commercial terms than Edifact content." Can you explain what the "segment incentive issue" is? Why don't the three GDS vendors offer NDC content on the same terms that they offer non-NDC content? What does the presence of the "segment incentive issue" reveal about the carriers' true motivations in pushing NDC?
A: In traditional GDS distribution, the airline pays a GDS a booking fee for every flight segment booked through it. Although the exact amounts of the fees are secret, experts generally agree that it is around three or four dollars per segment. The GDSs compete for agency business, so they share part of those fees with agencies as per-segment incentive payments under multiyear subscriber agreements. For many agencies, especially corporate-travel-oriented ones, those incentives are a major revenue source and sometimes the difference between profit and loss.
NDC changes that arithmetic. When a carrier distributes NDC content through a GDS, it negotiates separate commercial terms. The carrier's price for participating has generally been a substantially lower booking fee paid to the GDS vendor, or perhaps even none at all. As a result, GDSs typically pay agencies reduced incentives or none on NDC segments and sometimes charge the agency a fee instead for some NDC segments, depending on the carrier.
Even worse for agencies, under some GDS agreements with agencies, NDC segments don't count toward productivity quotas, so a shift to NDC booking can trigger shortfall payments or reduce incentive tiers on non-NDC segments. In my experience, both the level of NDC incentives and the inclusion in productivity quotas are negotiable, at least to some extent, depending on the agency's size, productivity and other factors.
As for the carriers' motivations, they promote NDC as a way to deliver richer content, ancillaries and personalized offers. Those benefits may be real, but if they were the airlines' primary motivations, they would have no reason to insist on different economics with the GDS vendors.
Their insistence on lower fees, together with the surcharges several carriers impose on traditional bookings, shows that a central purpose of NDC is really cost reduction. For a generation, carriers have wanted to cut what they pay to the GDS oligarchs to distribute through agencies, and NDC is the most successful lever that they have found.
For agencies, the segment incentive issue will not resolve itself. Before signing or renewing a GDS agreement, an agency should model its NDC booking mix, insist on written terms governing NDC incentives and quota credit and seek a right to renegotiate if a major carrier shifts its content to NDC.