FORT LAUDERDALE -- Cruise line presidents from Royal Caribbean Cruises Ltd. brands took on the subject of overtourism, the evolution of luxury cruising and female leadership during a panel at CruiseWorld.
Regarding overtourism, they said that in the general travel industry, cruise lines are a small part of the phenomenon -- but a highly visible one.
"Our reality is, perception rules," said Lisa Lutoff-Perlo, president of Celebrity Cruises. "There are these big white ships pulling in and it's a lot of people at once."
Larry Pimentel, president of Azamara, said that 25 years ago there were only 1.4 million outbound travelers from China; today there are 150 million. "India is also coming," he said. "By no means is this only a cruise issue; it is an industry issue."
And Mark Conroy, managing director of the Americas, for Silversea Cruises, said that overreacting to overtourism could be overly damaging to some local residents in destinations such as Venice.
"Tourism is the largest employer in the world overall," Conroy said. You can't just shut it down. If you banned all tourism into Venice, there'd be a big unemployment problem there."
Silversea redefining expedition cruising
Conroy said that 10 years ago when he was working for a rival company he thought that Silversea chairman Manfredi Lefebvre was crazy to bolt an expedition arm onto a luxury brand.
"I thought he'd lost his mind, until I saw the per diems from the expedition business," Conroy said.
Silversea, as a top-tier luxury brand, also brought a different concept to what was then more of a rustic product. At that time, Conroy recalled, "You had to sacrifice your lifestyle to go on an expedition."
But when Silversea renovated its two oldest ships, the Silver Cloud and Silver Wind, it decided to transform them into expedition vessels but with the space and amenities of a luxury ship.
Conroy said that one of the unintended consequences was that the larger ship had faster speeds than most expedition ships.
"We can cross the Drake Passage [to Antarctica] in 28 hours instead of two days," Conroy said
In defining the "luxury" appeal of his Azamara brand, Pimentel said that value plays a bigger part than in traditional luxury brands. As a department store, Azamara would compare to Nordstrom, he said.
"We're not Saks Fifth Avenue." As a car, we would be more like a Lexus."
A woman in charge
The panel followed the CEO Conversation between Royal
Caribbean Chairman Ltd. chairman and CEO Richard Fain and editor in
chief Arnie Weissmann, and Fain returned to the stage to co-moderate the panel
Lutoff-Perlo, who was named president of Celebrity five years ago, and Fain asked her what was is like to be one of the few women to run a cruise line. She said at first, she took it for granted.
"When I was appointed I didn't think about my gender at all," she said. "But then when I was appointed, to the rest of the world apparently it is a really big deal.
"The great part is the part I can do to pay it forward" to other females in the industry, she said.