Although hotel loyalty programs have uniformly ballooned in
size and scope, it’s also becoming clear that there’s no one-size-fits-all
approach when it comes to keeping program members loyal.
“The biggest moving piece with these hotel loyalty programs
is that consumer expectations are changing,” said Tom Caporaso, CEO of loyalty
program vendor Clarus Commerce. “Many are now more interested in instant
gratification, versus some of the high-points thresholds that some of the
legacy programs have traditionally focused on.”
Gary Leff, a points expert and author of the blog View From
the Wing, echoed Caporaso’s take, while adding that these days, “different
loyalty programs are doing better at different things.”
“While the overall trend with these programs has been getting
guests to book direct, we’re also starting to see some companies offer
redemptions that can be earned with a smaller number of points in the hope that
infrequent guests will view loyalty points as more valuable,” Leff said.
He cited recent efforts taken by Hilton, which, during a
July earnings call, detailed plans to continue ramping up focus on lower-level
members of its Hilton Honors platform.
Hilton CEO Christopher Nassetta told investors that
low-level members “may stay two, three, five nights a year, [but] the more that
that can be a direct source of business, rather than indirect, adds to our
RevPAR premiums, and it does so in an efficient way in terms of distribution
costs. Lower-level members don’t accumulate enough points to go to the
Maldives, [but] the more engagement, the more share of wallet we get, the more
that people are using their points and doing things that get them active in our
system, the more they spend with us.”
Among the partnerships that have provided Hilton Honors
members with more frequent redemption opportunities are recent tie-ins with
Lyft, granting guests the ability to earn and use points when using the
ridesharing app, and Amazon, with members now able to shop the online retail
giant using points.
Additionally, the group’s rollout of a sliding-scale payment
option, enabling members to adjust the amount of points they’d like to redeem
when booking a stay, has brought greater redemption flexibility.
These types of initiatives are in stark contrast with the
unique, once-in-a-lifetime experiences that many major loyalty platforms have
leveraged to court higher-level members. These experiences, including luxury
vacation packages or private tastings at exclusive restaurants, can be
purchased outright or bid on as part of an online auction platform, using
points.
Jeff Doane, senior vice president of sales and marketing for
Accor, said, “Loyalty programs are not viewing the customer simply as a
transaction anymore but as an individual who is looking for unique experiences
and moments based on what they are passionate about.”
Accor recently launched a revamped Accor Live Limitless
platform, which Doane said offers an expanded number of Limitless Experiences
that he bills as “highly coveted, money-can’t-buy” events.
Such exclusive experiences are notorious for often requiring
a large accumulation of points. For example, a recent Marriott Bonvoy auction
package that combined a visit to a private Grand Cayman estate and boat
excursion with a cooking master class led by chef David Bouley ultimately went
for 2 million points.
Leff said, “People who take advantage of these offers may
end up having a greater affinity for the brand. However, the best experiences
are very limited, and it’s hard for those to scale.”
Caporaso said that companies able to engage a broader pool
of members could have an edge.
“The things that are really valuable to the average traveler
are things like free internet, a room upgrade or late checkout,” Caporaso said.
“Most would prefer having a handful of small benefits.”
Also, the more frequently a guest redeems a reward, the
better chance a loyalty program might have of staying top of mind.
“Some of these legacy loyalty programs have a ‘set-and-forget’
mentality and may be forgetting that a guest is a member of upward of six or 12
different kinds of loyalty programs,” Caporaso said. “It’s a constant battle
for loyalty, and a competitor is always a click away.”